Paula Abdul - is it time for her to go?

object width="425" height="355">

My rundown:

Brook and Jason too one dimensional but good when they are in the Zone, for both of them - their first song was not at all good, both looked uncomfortable.

Saisha and David Archelletta - ready for Lawrence Welk.
(Let it be noted that Bill disagrees with my assessment of David A.)

David Cook - untouchable winner!!